All posts
4 min read

Circumvention vs. Compliance: Legitimate Strategies for Using Vietnam's FTAs Amidst Global Trade Scrutiny

Using Vietnam's FTAs? Understand the critical difference between legitimate compliance and illegal tariff circumvention amidst high global scrutiny. Learn the risks & best practices.
Written by
Victor Lee
Published on
April 8, 2025

Vietnam's extensive network of Free Trade Agreements (FTAs) like the CPTPP, RCEP, and EVFTA presents significant opportunities for businesses to access global markets with preferential tariffs. However, in a global climate marked by high tariffs and intense trade scrutiny, the line between legitimately utilizing these agreements and illegally circumventing duties is critically important – and heavily enforced. As Vietnam's role in global supply chains grows, so does the focus from international customs authorities on ensuring the origin claims of Vietnamese exports are valid. This article distinguishes between illegal circumvention and compliant strategies, outlining the risks and best practices for businesses operating in Vietnam.

Understanding the Risk: Why Scrutiny is High

Vietnam's strategic location, skilled workforce, and participation in multiple FTAs have made it an attractive hub for manufacturing and export. However, this also places it under the microscope of customs authorities in major importing countries (like the US and EU) concerned about tariff evasion. Specifically, there are concerns that goods truly originating from countries facing high tariffs might be minimally processed or simply transshipped through Vietnam to falsely claim Vietnamese origin and avoid duties (Source: Nomura Connects). Importing nations are increasing enforcement efforts, directing customs agencies to prioritize origin verification and impose strict penalties for non-compliance (Source: Trade Compliance Resource Hub).

What Constitutes Circumvention? (Red Flags)

Tariff circumvention involves practices designed to disguise the true origin of goods to avoid duties. This is illegal and distinct from legitimate use of FTAs. Red flags include:

  • Minimal Processing: Performing only simple assembly, repackaging, relabelling, or minor processing in Vietnam that does not meet the "substantial transformation" criteria (like required changes in tariff classification or sufficient regional value content) defined by the specific FTA's Rules of Origin (RoO).
  • False Origin Declarations: Knowingly providing incorrect information about the origin of goods on Certificates of Origin (C/O), self-declarations, or other customs documents.
  • Document Falsification: Using forged or altered documents to support a false claim of origin.
  • Transshipment: Routing goods through Vietnam without any significant production or transformation occurring, solely to benefit from Vietnam's trade agreements or lower tariff status.

The High Cost of Non-Compliance

Engaging in or facilitating tariff circumvention carries severe consequences:

  • Denial of FTA Benefits: Importing customs authorities will reject the preferential tariff claim, resulting in the application of standard (often much higher) duty rates.
  • Retroactive Duty Payments: Authorities can demand back-payment of duties for past shipments found to be non-compliant.
  • Significant Financial Penalties: Customs laws typically allow for substantial monetary penalties for false declarations or fraudulent activities, potentially multiples of the duties evaded. US Customs, for example, has been directed to impose maximum penalties in certain tariff enforcement scenarios (Source: Trade Compliance Resource Hub).
  • Anti-Circumvention Duties: Importing countries may impose additional anti-circumvention duties on specific goods from Vietnam if widespread evasion is suspected (Source: Vietnam Investment Review).
  • Increased Scrutiny & Delays: Non-compliant companies will likely face intensified inspections and delays for all future shipments.
  • Legal and Reputational Damage: Severe cases can lead to legal action against the importer/exporter and cause significant damage to a company's reputation and relationship with customs authorities globally.

Legitimate Strategies: Ensuring Compliance

Successfully leveraging Vietnam's FTAs requires a commitment to compliance through legitimate strategies:

  • Master the Specific Rules of Origin (RoO): Do not assume general rules apply. Thoroughly understand the exact RoO criteria (Change in Tariff Classification, Regional Value Content percentage, specific processing requirements, cumulation rules) for your specific product under the specific FTA (CPTPP, RCEP, EVFTA, ATIGA, etc.) you intend to use. (Source: Institute of Export & International Trade)
  • Ensure Substantial Transformation: Design and document production processes in Vietnam to demonstrably meet the relevant "substantial transformation" threshold required by the chosen FTA's RoO. This is the core difference between compliance and circumvention.
  • Maintain Meticulous Records: Keep comprehensive records proving the origin of all input materials (supplier declarations, C/Os for inputs) and detailing the production steps undertaken in Vietnam. This documentation is essential to substantiate origin claims if challenged by customs authorities during verification (Source: Vietnam Trade Portal / MOIT).
  • Implement Robust Compliance Programs: Establish clear internal procedures for determining origin, managing documentation, training relevant staff, and conducting periodic self-audits to ensure ongoing compliance. Consider using specialized software tools for complex supply chains.
  • Verify Supplier Information: Obtain and validate origin information for key components sourced from suppliers, especially when relying on cumulation rules within FTAs.

Partnering for Compliance

Navigating the complexities of multiple FTAs, varying RoO criteria, and rigorous customs enforcement requires expertise. Partnering with knowledgeable customs brokers, trade lawyers, or experienced shipping agents (like Lightspeed Marine) who understand both the legal requirements and the practicalities of Vietnamese operations can significantly reduce compliance risks and help implement legitimate, beneficial trade strategies.

Conclusion

Vietnam's extensive network of FTAs offers genuine pathways to preferential market access and supply chain optimization. However, these benefits can only be realized through strict adherence to the Rules of Origin and transparent documentation. Attempting to circumvent tariffs through minimal processing or false declarations carries substantial financial, legal, and reputational risks due to heightened global scrutiny. By prioritizing robust compliance programs, ensuring substantial transformation occurs in Vietnam, and working with knowledgeable partners, businesses can confidently and legitimately leverage Vietnam's FTA advantages for sustainable international trade.

Contact Lightspeed Marine for expert guidance on ensuring compliance and optimizing your logistics within Vietnam's trade framework.

Sources:

Need Expert Maritime Support?
Leverage our local expertise for smoother port calls, crew changes, and cost savings in Vietnam. Enquire today for personalized solutions.
Enquire Now